Matthew McConaughey

 

Photo of Matthew McConaughey

Image Source: All-Pro Reels from District of Columbia, USA, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What was the Accusation?

Actor Matthew McConaughey attracted national attention after an early-morning encounter with Austin, Texas, police on October 25, 1999. Officers responding to a neighbor’s complaint about loud music went to McConaughey’s home and reported seeing the 29-year-old actor naked and playing percussion instruments. According to contemporary reporting based on a police affidavit, an officer said he smelled marijuana after entering the residence and found a pipe and a bowl containing marijuana stems and seeds. McConaughey was arrested on probable cause involving marijuana possession and drug paraphernalia as well as resistance to the officers. He spent several hours in custody before being released on $1,000 bond.

The legal outcome was substantially less serious than the initial reports suggested. Travis County authorities declined to pursue the drug allegations, saying the facts did not support those charges. Contemporary reports described the remaining allegation as resisting arrest or resisting transportation. McConaughey ultimately resolved the episode as a noise violation and paid a $50 fine. In later accounts, including his 2020 memoir Greenlights, McConaughey disputed the way police entered and handled the encounter and openly acknowledged resisting them. Rather than issue a conventional apology, he repeatedly treated the incident with humor and defended the private conduct that preceded the arrest. In a later interview, he questioned what was wrong with playing drums in his “birthday suit” and said he had no regrets about how he ended up in jail. His response therefore functions as an unusual celebrity apologia: instead of mortification, McConaughey relied primarily on justification, minimization, and an attack on aspects of the police response. Over time, he incorporated the episode into his public persona, retelling it in interviews and his memoir and, decades later, humorously revisiting it in a promotional campaign.

Key Apologia Strategies:

Minimization, Attacking the Accuser, Bolstering

Video

N/A

Transcript

Public Response After Release from Jail (October 25, 1999):

“I don’t want to rent a place there, but it was a nice stay for a night.”

Comments on the incidents from his book Greenlights (2020):

“For me, the congas, bongos, and djembe have always been the purest and most instinctual instruments. No sticks, no electricity, no equalizer, no strings, no tools or amendments, just skin to skin with the most analogue spoken language, prayer, and dance known to man—the percussion. The root of music, from the roots of music, Africa. It was time to lose my mind in it, take flight into the haze, and slip into the dream. It was time for a jam session.

What I didn’t know was that while I was banging away in my bliss, two Austin policemen also thought it was time to barge into my house unannounced, wrestle me to the ground with nightsticks, handcuff me, and pin me to the floor.”

“Ohhh, looky who we got here,” the ’roided-up cop with a crew cut, who looked like a Nebraska Cornhusker himself, said as he read the driver’s license he picked up off my coffee table. Then he picked up the bong. “And looky what we got here. Mr. McConaughey, you are under arrest for disturbing the peace, possession of marijuana, and resisting arrest,” he proudly stated while squatting atop me, knee in my back.”

“Fuck you, motherfucker! You broke in my house! Fuck, yeah, I resisted!”
“That’s enough!” he grunted, then wrangled me to my feet. “We’re takin you downtown.”
The other officer, the more civil one of the two, grabbed a blanket off the couch and moved to wrap it around my body.
“Ohhhh no!” I barked. “I’m not putting shit on! My naked ass is proof I was mindin my own business!”
They escorted me out of my house through the courtyard entry on the way to the street. Still naked and reluctant to submit to the inevitability of my predicament, I got relative, and decided it would be a clever idea to run up the walls left and right of the gated passageway and do a somersault backflip over the Cornhusker cop who was guiding me from behind. My thinking was that in midflight, while upside down in the air, I would assume a pike position and then slide my cuffed wrists under my butt and up and over my legs, then stick the landing behind the Cornhusker, now with my fettered hands in front of me.
“My rationale at the time was that after pulling off such an extraordinary Houdini-like stunt, the officers would be so impressed that they would abrogate the arrest and set me free. I know, stupid, but remember, I’d been celebrating for thirty-two and a half hours straight.
Whether my plan of action was physically possible or not, I’ll never know. It didn’t happen. Instead, before I’d taken three steps up the wall, the Cornhusker body slammed me back down onto the brick footpath.”
“Meanwhile, word must have spread over the police scanner as to just who had been arrested because there on the street were six lit-up cop cars and about forty of my neighbors.
“Sure you don’t want this blanket?” the civil cop asked again.
“Hell no, this is PROOF of my innocence!!” I yelled to everyone on the block and one more over.”

They lowered my head, put me in the back of the patrol car, and drove me to the precinct. After we landed and I declined the third offer to wear the blanket, we headed up the steps toward the entrance of the Austin Police Department. At the double doors to admissions, a six-foot-six, 285-pound, tatted-up, working inmate greeted me just outside the entryway. He was holding a pair of men’s orange institutional pants. Before he could say a word, I said, “Proof of my innocence, man.”

“He just looked at me, seeming to understand but knowing better. “We all innocent, man. Trust me, you do wanna put these on.” Maybe it was his honest eyes or the fact that he was a fellow offender, or maybe it was the sudden realization that, when a six-foot, six-inch jailbird built like a brick shithouse tells you You do wanna put on some pants before you go in the clink, it’s probably best to listen. “OK.” He dropped to his knees, opened up the pant legs, and shimmied the prison cottons up my shanks until the elastic waistband was around mine; then, I headed for the pokey.”

“At 9:30 a.m., my thirty-two-and-a-half-hour buzz now turned hangover, I was sitting in the corner of the cell when two people showed up on the other side of the bars. “Mr. McConaughey, I’m Judge Penny Wilkov and this is criminal defense attorney Joe Turner.” An orderly unlocked the cell door.”

“I don’t know how in the hell a disturbing the peace call escalated into a class A misdemeanor of resisting arrest and a class B misdemeanor of possession of less than two ounces of marijuana,” the judge said, “or why two of our police officers forcibly entered your home without fair warning. I am going to dismiss the disturbing the peace and possession misdemeanors and give you a personal recognizance bond on the resisting arrest. I don’t understand or agree with how this situation escalated.” “Well, Judge Penny, I’m not sure what that all that means, but I don’t either,” I said.”

“Joe Turner, who was the same attorney who successfully defended Willie Nelson years earlier in a possession case, spoke up. “Judge, we all agree that this situation got out of hand very quickly, but you also gotta understand that these policemen literally broke into this man’s house while he was playing some bongos in his birthday suit! The resisting arrest was self-defense! I suggest you dismiss it altogether and my client will plead to the class C violation of a sound ordinance as he was indeed bangin on those bongos pretty damn loud for 2:36 in the morning.”

“Deal, case closed,” said the judge.

“What’s that mean?” I asked.

Joe pulled out his wallet, grabbed a fifty-dollar bill, waved it in my face, then looked at me and said, “Means I’ll pay your get-out-of-jail fee and you owe me fifty bucks, you’re free to go. I got a car waitin for ya at the back entrance or you can meet the press out front, there’s plenty of em waitin. Here’s a bag of fresh clothes your neighbor dropped off for ya.”

“I thanked them both, got dressed in the lavatory, splashed my face with cold water, and tried to breathe out the blues that were starting to set in. Why the blues, you ask? Well, obviously I was lucky, walking out of jail only $50 poorer—this didn’t happen to everyone who got hauled in on charges like resisting arrest and marijuana possession. The problem was, as I’ve said, in my family, we didn’t get in trouble for committing the crime, we got in trouble for getting caught. I wasn’t raised to end up in jail, for anything or any amount of time, and even though my offense was one I’d committed many times before and would many times more, I got caught, and for that, I felt guilty. Outlaw logic.”

“Looking for some fearless consolation, I decided to call my mom before I chose which way to leave my first prison stint. Maybe it was the fact that while I was sure she would have no mercy for my circumstance, at the same time I knew she would pour a drink and toast to how it was I got into it. Was it going to be her that answered or was it going to be that new groupie fan? I didn’t know. Turns out it was both.”

“They what, Matthew?! Broke into your house!? Those son of a bitches, you keep your head up,” she said. “There is nothing wrong with smokin a little fun stuff and playing your drums naked at night in your own home; who do they think they are comin in your house like that?!” Just what I needed. I hung up and decided to stride toward the media mob out front instead of sneaking out the back.”

Excerpt from Matthew McConaughey’s Playboy interview in 2016:

“I saw the cop’s eyes get big when he identified me, and it became, ‘Oh, look what we’ve got here.’ My first call was to my mother. I was feeling guilty because I was not raised to be in jail. What’s wrong with beating on your drums in your birthday suit? I have no regrets about the way I got there. But what’s the lesson? Shut the window that has the beautiful scent of jasmine blowing in because it’s two in the morning and you might wake a neighbor.”

Related Apologia Cases

Readers interested in this celebrity apologia case may also want to review:

Sources

CBS News. (1999, October 25). Actor McConaughey arrested. CBS News. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/actor-mcconaughey-arrested/

E! News. (2016, December 13). 8 bonkers quotes from Matthew McConaughey’s Playboy interview. https://www.eonline.com/news/815548/8-bonkers-quotes-from-matthew-mcconaughey-s-playboy-interview

McConaughey, M. (2020). Greenlights. Crown.

MovieWeb. (n.d.). Matthew McConaughey’s naked bongos arrest details. https://movieweb.com/matthew-mcconaughey-naked-bongos-arrest-details/

Raposas, R., & O’Brien, K. (2024, November 22). Matthew McConaughey reveals what his mom said after his 1999 naked bongo arrest. People. https://people.com/matthew-mcconaughey-got-arrested-for-naked-bongo-playing-what-his-mom-said-8750076

The Guardian. (1999, October 26). Drug charges dropped against EdTV actor. https://www.theguardian.com/film/1999/oct/26/news

White, A. (2020, October 21). Matthew McConaughey was naked, high and playing the bongos during infamous 1999 arrest, memoir reveals. The Independent. https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/films/news/matthew-mcconaughey-arrest-naked-bongos-greenlights-memoir-b1200362.html